According to FINRA, Patrick Richard Daley was fined $5,000 and suspended for 30 days for engaging in outside business activities without providing prior written notice to his member firm.
Daley became an owner and board member of a meat processing company. He orally informed his firm that he had invested in the company but did not disclose that he served on the company's board and made strategic business decisions with the other owners in areas such as hiring and equipment purchasing. Similarly, Daley became an owner of a real estate investment company in partnership with other owners. He orally informed the firm of his investment but did not disclose that he engaged in management activity, including participating in strategic business decisions.
Daley did not provide any written notice to the firm of these management and board activities until after the firm received inquiries from FINRA. This pattern of partial oral disclosure while omitting material details is particularly problematic. Daley disclosed his financial investments in these companies but concealed his active management roles.
Outside business activities must be disclosed in writing so firms can evaluate potential conflicts of interest, time commitment issues, and supervisory concerns. Serving on a corporate board and making strategic business decisions requires significant time and attention. These activities could have interfered with Daley's ability to serve his investment clients properly. Additionally, his roles in these businesses could have created conflicts of interest if any of his investment clients had interests related to meat processing or real estate.
The failure to disclose active management roles while disclosing passive investments suggests Daley understood he had disclosure obligations but attempted to minimize or conceal the extent of his outside activities. A truly inadvertent failure would typically involve complete non-disclosure, not selective disclosure of only certain aspects of the activity.
Neither outside business activity involved firm customers, which somewhat mitigates the seriousness of the violation. However, the failure to properly disclose these activities still violated FINRA rules and prevented the firm from properly supervising Daley's activities and evaluating potential conflicts.
For investors, this case illustrates that representatives may have outside business interests that create conflicts or divide their attention. Investors should ask their financial professionals directly about outside business activities and whether those activities could create conflicts or affect the representative's ability to serve clients. The suspension was in effect from June 6, 2022, through July 5, 2022.